Judge orders OpenAI to turn over hiring records in Apple trade secrets case

A federal judge has ruled that Apple can obtain expedited access to OpenAI's hiring materials as part of the trade secrets lawsuit Apple filed against OpenAI in July. The ruling, issued by U.S. District Judge Edward Davila, covers documents tied to OpenAI's interviews with former Apple employees who applied for positions in OpenAI's consumer hardware and robotics groups, ahead of the rumored launch of OpenAI's first hardware device.
The materials Apple can review include interview checklists, guides, instructions, manuals and scripts, plus technical presentations and records indicating that interview discussions referenced Apple technology or components. OpenAI has five days to produce materials it has already collected and 14 days for anything else covered by this request. The judge agreed with Apple that the documents warranted expedited treatment.
Apple's lawsuit accuses OpenAI of a pattern of theft. The complaint includes allegations that former employees used Apple laptops to download confidential material and files describing unannounced technologies, features and products, including technical specifications, engineering presentations and proprietary project data. Apple also claims that former Apple employees now at OpenAI coached others considering a move to OpenAI on what information to bring to interviews.
Davila did not grant every Apple request. He allowed access to the interview materials and to private LINE messages between individuals named in the case, including OpenAI employees Chang Liu and Alyssa Peng. He also approved depositions for Liu and Peng, along with a third person, OpenAI chief hardware officer Tang Yew Tan. All three are former Apple employees.
The judge declined to expedite Apple's access to OpenAI's research and development in specific areas such as metal finishes and power management. He also denied several broader discovery requests, including access to OpenAI's hardware research and to information about what its former employees created while at OpenAI. That denial is not final: the judge left room for Apple to narrow its requests and try again.
The context here is competitive as much as legal. OpenAI is developing a consumer hardware device that could, in time, potentially rival the iPhone or smartphones more generally if an AI device becomes central to how consumers engage with software and services. Apple's suit, and its discovery push, appear aimed at understanding what former employees carried with them into that effort. Trade secret cases in California and elsewhere typically turn on whether information qualifies as a protectable secret and whether it was misappropriated; early discovery fights like this one are usually about scope rather than the merits.
The line between an employee's general skills and knowledge and an employer's confidential information is fact-intensive. Interview materials are relevant in that framing because they could show whether hiring conversations steered toward Apple-specific technical detail. The ruling's mix of grants and denials reflects that the court is weighing relevance and burden, not deciding the underlying claims.
Why it matters: For developers and product teams, the ruling signals that hiring and interview records can become discoverable evidence in trade secret disputes, which raises the stakes for how companies document recruiting of employees from competitors. For OpenAI, the near-term obligations are procedural but concrete: produce collected materials within five days and the rest within 14, and prepare Liu, Peng and Tan for depositions. Apple retains an option to narrow and refile its broader requests, so the discovery perimeter may still expand. The underlying suit remains unresolved.
Based on reporting from the original publisher. Visit the source for full context and later updates.
Publisher excerpt
A federal judge ruled that Apple can access OpenAI's interview materials involving former Apple employees, as well as private messages and testimony from key figures in the case.