AivexaNewsSearch
AI news for builders and product teamsChecked every hour

AI elites might hoard intelligence like mercantilists hoarded gold

Collected Nov 2, 2026

Engineer Venkatesh Rao published an essay on his tech blog Contraptions arguing that the debate over AI and employment is framed too narrowly around lost jobs. In his account, that framing overlooks how much more intelligence people will be able to put to use once AI lowers the cost of difficult work.

Rao draws an analogy to mercantilism, the economic doctrine that preceded capitalism. Mercantilists, he writes, treated wealth as finite, bound up with land and gold, and counted ordinary people only as labor. His claim is that many present-day elites treat intelligence the same way: as a scarce and dangerous resource that experts should manage, keep expensive and withhold from rivals. On this view, openly available AI models look like a threat, and Rao suggests some AI executives exploit safety fears to gain political influence.

The historical counterpoint he offers is early capitalism. People then chose to work about 300 days a year rather than 250 in order to buy goods such as tea or sugar. Rao sees a possible parallel with AI: people might end up thinking more, not less, because AI makes projects feasible that were previously too hard or too costly. Demand for ideas would then grow instead of human workers becoming obsolete.

From this he derives a political conclusion. The focus, Rao argues, should be fair access to AI rather than protecting legacy knowledge jobs. He extends the argument to AI agents, suggesting even autonomous systems could pursue their own projects and generate new demand for intelligence. Such agents need guardrails, in his view, but should not be reduced to simply following orders.

My reading is that the essay's core move is to treat intelligence as something whose supply can expand, rather than as a fixed pool to be rationed. That reframing cuts against both the displacement narrative and the safety-first posture that Rao associates with incumbents. It is an argument about demand and access rather than a forecast with numbers attached, and it leaves open how fair access would be achieved in practice.

Why it matters: Teams building or procuring AI tools are often evaluated on which jobs the technology replaces. Rao's essay suggests an alternative lens, in which cheaper capability expands the set of projects worth attempting and raises demand for human judgment. For product leaders, that is an argument for measuring new work created alongside work displaced — an inference on my part, not a claim in the essay.

Read at The Decoder

Based on reporting from the original publisher. Visit the source for full context and later updates.

Publisher excerpt

Engineer Venkatesh Rao compares the fear of AI job losses to mercantilism: intelligence is treated as a scarce resource that elites want to control. But AI could boost demand for human thinking, much like early capitalism made people voluntarily work more. The article AI elites might hoard intelligence like mercantilists hoarded gold appeared first on The Decoder .