Benn Jordan on Flock, privacy, and the new surveillance backlash

Musician and YouTuber Benn Jordan has become a leading public critic of Flock Safety, the maker of automatic license plate readers and the software network behind them, and recently testified before Congress at a hearing held by the Senate Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism devoted to Flock and other ALPR systems. The Verge frames that hearing as the culmination of months of growing, bipartisan criticism of Flock, pushback the outlet compares to the backlash against AI data centers.
The fallout has been concrete. Hundreds of cities, counties and other local governments have begun canceling contracts with the company. Republican Sen. Josh Hawley is investigating Flock, and Reuters reported last week that the company plans to cut roughly 18 percent of its workforce.
Jordan's path into the story is local. He lives in Atlanta, which he says has more Flock cameras per square mile than anywhere else. About two years ago he began noticing the devices, assumed they were traffic cameras, and then started looking into what they actually did and into security vulnerabilities. He describes himself as a lifelong musician who has always taken things apart, and says most of what the public is now discovering is simply that these systems have existed all along.
The technical core of his argument is the distinction between camera hardware and network. ALPRs date to the 1970s, Jordan says, and reached US policing in the late 1980s and 1990s; the classic deployment was a unit mounted on a patrol car so an officer could run a plate to dispatch without typing while driving. Flock's innovation, in his telling, is a private nationwide network that any participating police department or city can opt into and share data through, with 30 days of retention. Agencies across the country can then search a plate and reconstruct where a vehicle has been almost anywhere in the country, so an officer in Texas could trace someone's movement through New York or Atlanta. He says the plate-reading hardware itself is unremarkable, and that the network, not the camera, is the problem.
The legal claim is the sharper one. Jordan says this sharing happens without a warrant, whereas earlier ALPR data sharing ran through the National Crime Information Center, which he says requires a magistrate judge to weigh the context and issue a warrant before tracking. By operating a private database rather than the government-run system, he argues, Flock was able to sidestep that warrant process. This is his characterization of a legal gap; the company has disputed critics' framing of its practices, though the source excerpt does not include its specific response.
He also pushes back on the deterrence case that surveillance vendors make, the idea that enough cameras in enough places will drive crime toward zero, an argument Jamie Siminoff of Ring has made on the same podcast. Jordan notes that no city has ever been tested in a vacuum with cameras added and nothing else changed, and offers a shoplifting analogy: putting a camera in one supermarket aisle tends to push theft into other aisles rather than turn shoplifters into plumbers, and small stores that cannot afford camera networks may absorb the displaced activity. He adds that resource limits matter: following one car through public traffic cameras for 30 days would take enormous effort, which historically meant serious crimes justified it, and easy network queries make it cheap to chase leads on nonviolent offenses instead.
Jordan's critique is not aimed at Flock alone. He says he does not hate the company and views its posture toward critics as a colossal public relations failure that made it low-hanging fruit, while competitors such as Axon and Motorola quietly build comparable networks. He talks directly with Flock, including CEO Garrett Langley, and reports security vulnerabilities to the company when he finds them, describing that outreach as an olive branch meant to produce tangible fixes rather than to dismantle one vendor. He argues the real subject is the interlocking relationship between private industry, government and law enforcement that favors secrecy over transparency, and that nobody voted for an insecure camera network on every corner or was asked whether police with a record of abusing access should have it.
The contrast he draws is between Flock's startup-style public persona and the incumbents. He attributes part of the backlash to Langley's willingness to go on television and deride critics as left-wing terrorists, a strategy he says backfired, and to the company denying security vulnerabilities while redefining terms. Companies like Axon, he suggests, are duller journalistic targets by design because government contractors prefer anonymity. This suggests the accountability pressure may be concentrated on the most visible vendor rather than the category.
He is encouraged that the fight has moved into local politics, where residents are learning who their mayor and city council members are and showing up to meetings. He points to Asheville, North Carolina, where dissatisfaction with local surveillance policy could produce a new mayor with other progressive priorities. He is also disappointed that Flock has become a buzzword: he notes a Democratic candidate for governor in Georgia campaigning against Flock despite having welcomed the company as mayor of Atlanta, and says some officials denounce Flock and then sign with Axon, Verkada or Motorola.
Why it matters: procurement and policy teams at local governments now face real public scrutiny over ALPR contracts, and vendors should expect questions about data sharing, retention windows and warrant requirements to be asked in open session, not just in closed briefings. For developers and product teams building camera, computer-vision or data-sharing features, the case illustrates how a private database can become a compliance and reputational issue even when the sensing hardware is ordinary. The likeliest shift, as inference, is that contract terms around data retention and cross-agency search will get more attention than camera specifications, and that quieter competitors may inherit demand without facing the same scrutiny.
Based on reporting from the original publisher. Visit the source for full context and later updates.
Publisher excerpt
Today, I’m talking with Benn Jordan, musician, YouTuber, researcher, and investigative journalist. You might know Benn from those first two titles — he’s got a prolific discography of experimental music dating back decades. But in the last couple of years, he’s become a high-profile face in the creator and media spaces for his work investigating […]